The Best Innerspring Mattresses

What is an innerspring mattress? Compared to foam or latex, innerspring mattresses — AKA traditional coil or spring mattresses — are considered one of the oldest types of mattresses on the market. Consumers love innerspring mattresses because they’re comfortable, durable, and simple in construction. This doesn’t, however, make picking the right one a straightforward process. To help, we put together a guide of our top five innerspring mattress contenders.

Top 5 innerspring mattresses

• Best overall: WinkBeds
• Best for your budget: IKEA Hesstun Eurotop Mattress
• Best for combination sleepers: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
• Best for heavy sleepers: Big Fig
• Best organic mattress: Birch

These mattresses were chosen based on their price, quality, shopping benefits, firmness levels, and size options. We looked at ten contenders across the market, and narrowed the field based on customer reviews. Prices and features are valid as of October 2020.

Best for overall: WinkBeds

If you’re looking for the cushioning comfort of gel foam mattresses, but want the dynamic support of an innerspring, this is one of the best innerspring mattresses. It’s best for sleepers who want a cool and breathable mattress or suffer from back pain. With prices ranging between $1,050 for a twin and $1,850 for a California king, WinkBed is a hybrid that meets multiple needs.

Four different firmness levels go from softer, luxury firm, firmer, to plus. Shopping perks include fast and free delivery and a free 120-night trial. There’s also a lifetime warranty and durability guarantee. Each innerspring mattress is made to order within the United States. If the firmness doesn’t satisfy, it’s easy to exchange for a different mattress.

WinkBeds Mattress details

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California king
• Mattress height: 13.5″
• Models offered: Six models with four firmness levels

Pros and cons of WinkBeds Mattresses

Best for your budget: IKEA Hesstun Eurotop Mattress

If you’re looking for a high-quality innerspring mattress for under $500, IKEA’s queen-sized Hesstun is an excellent option. Prices range from $480 for a full to $650 for a king. It features a pillow-top as well as quilted foams and micro-coils for optimal comfort.

These mattresses are available in-store and online with three firmness levels, making them optimal for back and stomach sleepers. Reviews on IKEA’s website indicate that, even after six months, customers love that this mattress is comfortable, firm, supportive, and has no indentations. IKEA offers a risk-free 365-day sleep trial so, if it doesn’t meet your expectations, you can return or exchange it hassle-free.

IKEA Hesstun Eurotop Mattress details

• Sizes: Full, Queen and King
• Mattress height:
  • Full: 17 1/4″
  • Queen: 14 1/4″
  • King: 14 1/4″
• Models offered: Firm, medium-firm and plush

Pros and cons of IKEA Hesstun Eurotop mattresses

Best for combination sleepers: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

No matter if you’re a back sleeper or you switch from the stomach to back, the Brooklyn Bedding collection has the comfort and support you need. Price points range between $600 for a twin and $1,250 for a California King. This hybrid innerspring mattress has a premium quilted top, two-inch layer of patented TitanFlex foam, a second two-inch layer of Energex foam, and a cooling surface infusion.

Buy this bed-in-a-box directly from the Brooklyn Bedding website or through online retailers. It comes with not only a risk-free 120-night sleep trial and free shipping and returns but also a full 10-year warranty. Customers on Amazon love that they don’t sink into this mattress and that it offers firmness and support.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress details

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King
• Mattress height: 11 1/2″
• Models offered: Soft, medium, and firm for all types of sleepers

Pros and cons of Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattresses

Best for heavy sleepers: Big Fig

Ranging from $1,300 for a twin to $2,000 for a California King, Big Fig’s prices also include a heavy-duty bed frame. Even though this innerspring mattress features only one firmness level, it is one of a handful of brands that can support up to 1,100 pounds. In addition to the layer of gel-infused perforated foam and three layers of high-density polyfoam, there are also pocketed spring coils.

Notable perks are the 20-year warranty, free shipping and returns, and risk-free 120-night sleep trial. This mattress is best for those who sleep hot and have a higher than average weight. The heavy-duty foundation and quality of mattress materials prevent sagging, lack of edge support, and loss of comfort. ThermoGel technology delivers coolness, and high-density edge foam offers the best edge support. Positive reviews show that fans love the quality, comfort, and design.

Big Fig Mattress details

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King
• Mattress height: 13″
• Models offered: Innerspring mattress supporting up to 1,100 pounds

Pros and cons of Big Fig mattresses

Best organic mattress: Birch

The Birch innerspring mattress line consists of organic products with a medium firmness level. Prices range from $1,050 for a twin and $1,800 for a California King, featuring optimal airflow, breathability, and pressure relief. Because this company is fairly new – they launched in 2019 – the only place you can find their mattresses is on their website.

Once you choose a mattress it ships free in a box within five to 10 business days. Enjoy a 100-night sleep trial for this non-toxic mattress. There is also a 25-year warranty so, if anything happens, it’s covered. These mattresses are ideal for all types of sleepers, including side, back, and stomach sleepers.

Birch Mattress details

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King
• Mattress height: 10″
• Models offered: One type — medium-firm mattress; if you want it softer, they offer an optional organic top.

Pros and cons of Birch mattresses

Choosing the right mattress material

Hybrid, memory foam and innerspring mattresses are some of the most popular types of mattresses on the market. Choosing the right material involves understanding the mattress construction as well as comfort qualities. There is no right or wrong material. But the firmness level is an indicator of comfort. For example, a side sleeper needs a softer mattress while stomach sleepers benefit from firmer. Back sleepers fall somewhere in the middle with medium-firm mattresses.

If you like a little bounce, an innerspring mattress is an ideal choice. However, if you’re looking for pressure relief, memory foam may be better. For those who want plushness with a bit of bounce, a hybrid mattress is optimal because it combines the qualities of an innerspring mattress with those of memory foam. If your sleeping partner tosses and turns a lot, try an innerspring mattress with pocketed coils to help with motion isolation.

Things to consider when shopping for mattresses

Finding the best innerspring mattress can be overwhelming, with such a wide variety of choices on the market. This is especially true if you suffer from aches and pains; choosing the wrong mattress can mean more of that throughout the day.  Though choosing a mattress is based a lot on preference, there are some things to consider:

• Determine if an innerspring, memory foam or hybrid mattress best suits your needs
• Talk to your healthcare provider for a recommendation
• Test out mattresses in stores and make sure you’re not rushing
• Firm mattresses aren’t always the best pick, especially if you suffer from lower back pain
• Browse reviews about these mattresses and make sure there is a good warranty

The bottom line

Innerspring mattresses provide breathability, durability, and support. While they’re a traditional choice, their popularity hasn’t diminished. Look at both the construction of a mattress as well as its firmness level to determine the best innerspring mattress for you.

Frequently asked questions

Do you need a box spring with an innerspring mattress?

It depends. If you’re using the mattress on the floor or a wooden platform, then a box spring isn’t necessary. But if you’re using a standard bed frame, then you’ll need one.

What is the difference between innerspring and pocket coil mattresses?

Innerspring mattresses transfer motion each time one sleeper or their partner moves. Pocked coil technology helps remove some of that motion transfer.

What is the best innerspring mattress for side sleepers?

According to Consumer Affairs, the best innerspring mattresses for side sleepers are by manufacturers including Casper, Helix, Loam and Leaf, Nest, and Saatva.

What is the best innerspring mattress for low back pain?

Women’s Health indicates that the best innerspring mattresses for back pain are sold by Sleep Innovations, Sweetnight, Casper, Allswell, and Sealy.